top of page
Search

When does a seizing plaintiff have to post countersecurity? A recent New Orleans federal court decision says: not always.

Nov 3
2 min read


Under Supplemental Admiralty Rule E(7)(a), when a defendant posts security to free its vessel and then asserts a counterclaim arising from the same incident, the plaintiff generally must post countersecurity for that counterclaim “unless the court, for cause shown, directs otherwise.” The purpose is to put the parties on equal footing.


In Curry v. M/V CHEMTRANS TAURUS (E.D. La. Oct. 30, 2026), a 63-foot fishing vessel collided with a 745-foot foreign-flagged tanker. The plaintiffs, a commercial fishing family, seized the tanker, and its owner posted a $2,000,000 letter of undertaking. The tanker interests then counterclaimed for damages and contribution and demanded $300,000 in countersecurity, with proceedings stayed until it was posted.

The Court denied the motion. Applying the Fifth Circuit’s Titan Navigation factors, the court found:


  • The plaintiffs had shown they could not afford to post security. Since the collision, one has earned about $240 a week power washing, and the other $200–$300 a week working on a crabbing boat.

  • Requiring countersecurity would effectively force them to abandon their claim through an indefinite stay or dismissal.

  • There was no parallel security concern. The plaintiffs are Louisiana residents, and their vessel sits on land in Slidell, so there is no risk they will flee the jurisdiction. The tanker, by contrast, is mobile.

  • With trial about a month away, a stay would serve little purpose other than to halt the litigation.


The court agreed that financial hardship alone does not automatically excuse countersecurity. Even so, it held that “the circumstances of each case must govern,” and these circumstances did not warrant it. The court also rejected the tanker interests’ alternative request to void and return the $2M letter of undertaking.


The takeaway: Rule E(7) reads as mandatory, but courts keep real discretion. Where countersecurity would shut down an individual plaintiff’s case, and that plaintiff poses no flight risk, the equities can tip against it.



Please feel free to reach out at ad@adamdavislawfirm.com or (504) 553-1435 if you have any questions or would like to discuss.


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page